PASTOR’S PERSPECTIVE: “DOING WHAT ALL THE KING’S HORSES AND ALL THE KING’S COULD NOT DO”.
(By: Ron Woodrum)
One of the most interesting movies of the 1970’s was the 1976 movie All The President’s Men, starring Robert Redford and Dustin Hoffman. The movie was about how two Washington Post reporters-Carl Bernstein and Bob Woodward-played a vital role in uncovering the Watergate Break-In and Watergate Scandal. E.Howard Hunt and G. Gordon Liddy, working for President Nixon, masterminded a break-in and wiretapping of the Democratic National Committee headquarters in 1972. The names Virgilio Gonzalez, Benard Barker, James McCord, Eugenio Martinez, and Frank Sturgis were not household names. But those were the five that were hired to break in and tap the phones of the Democrats. On the night of June 17, 1972 they entered the Democratic headquarters, through doors entering from the parking garage, that were rigged with tape, to remain unlocked after closing time. Another unrecognizable name, Frank Wills, the Security Guard working the building that night, found the doors rigged and called the police, fearing a break-in. The police arrived to capture the burglars red-handed. The leading burglar-James McCord had papers and money in his pocket linking him to E.Howard Hunt, G. Gordon Liddy, and eventually Richard Nixon, and all the President’s men, who were implicit in the attempted cover-up that followed, and ended in President Nixon resigning the Presidency, on August 9, 1974. After the President was informed of the break-in, he and his 12 closest men decided it was not that big of a deal, and if they would all stick together, stick to their story, they could weather the storm and it would pass without implicating them. But like “‘all the king’s horses and all the king’s men in Humpty Dumpty’s fall-all the President’s men could not pull it off either”. One of the casualties of the Watergate Cover-Up was President Nixon’s hatchet man-Chuck Colson. This Scandal sent Colson to prison in June of 1974, for seven months, for obstructiion of justice. He was born again, after reading C.S. Lewis’ Mere Christianity, just before going to prison. He wrote a best selling book describing his conversion titled Born Again. While in prison he was so affected by what he saw that his life was changed forever. He gave up a lucrative career to lead a life of ministry to prisoners, all over the world, called Prison Fellowship. He described his call to that ministry in his second book-Life Sentence. But it was in his third book, Loving God, that Colson linked the Scandal of Watergate to the Resurrection of Jesus Christ. He said that watching all the president’s men fail to keep the cover-up together convinced him that the resurrection of Jesus Christ is the most proven and established fact of history. How? Because “All the Saviour’s Men” did what “All the king’s horses and all the king’s men, and all the president’s men could never do!”
In Colson’s words all that the President’s men had to do was to stick together and stick to their story. “But after March 21, 1973 everything changed-it was all downhill, and fast! Conversations grew thick and heavy as they talked about perjury, obstruction of justice, and stonewalling…the kind of talk that gives grown mean weak knees and sweaty palms”. Colson goes on to explain, “with the most powerful office in the world at stake, a small band of hand-picked loyalists…could not hold a conspiracy together for more than two weeks…the natural human instinct for self-preservation was so ooverwhelming that the conspirators, one by one, deserted their leader, walked away from their cause, turned their backs on the power, prestige, and privileges”. What does all this have to do with the Resurrection of Jesus?
Colson says when it comes to believing in or rejecting the Resurection of Jesus Christ one only has two choices. One is to accept the testimony of the disciples as true evidence of His resurrection. “The other is to reject it as fraud, and one must conclude that there was a conspiracy-a cover-up if you will- by eleven men with the complicity of up to five hundred others. To subscribe to this argument, one must also be ready to believe that each disciple was willing to be ostracized by friends and family, live in daily fear of death, endure prisons, live penniless and hungry, sacrifice family, be tortured without mercy, and ultimately die-without ever once renouncing that Jesus had risen from the dead! That is why the Watergate experience is so instructive for me. If John Dean and the rest of of were so panic-stricken, not by beatings and execution,…but by political disgrace and possible prison terms, one can only speculate about the emotions of the disciples. Unlike the men in the White House, the disciples were powerless people, abandoned by their leader, homeless in a conquered land. Yet they clung tenaciously to their enormously offensive story that their leader had risen from His ignoble death and was alive-and was the Lord.” Remember that the normal reaction to all that had happened was to deny the Lord, like Peter did. But after witnessing the real bodily resurrection of Jesus, they knew that Jesus had conquered death, and there was nothing to fear now standing for the truth, even if it cost them their lives. Colson concludes-“take it from one who was inside the Watergate web looking out, who saw firsthand how vulnerable a cover-up is: Nothing less than a witness as awesome as the resurrected Christ could have caused those men to maintain to their dying whispers that Jesus is alive and Lord.”
The only alternative to believing that truth is to believe that the disciples perpetrated a conspiracy and hoax until their last breaths, staying united in their stories. They were willing to die for a lie. Watergate proves that to be an impossibility. Edward Gibbon, the noted historian, in his famous work The History of the Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire, states that the “pure and austere morality of the first Christians” was one of the reasons for the fast growth of the early Church. They were hardly candidates to perpetrate a lie. Michael Green, scholar and principal of St. Johns College, summarized why the early disciples could hold to their story-it was because it was the truth. He writes, “the resurrection was the belief that turned heart-broken followers of a crucified rabbi into courageous witnesses and martyrs…you could flog them, imprison them, kill them but you could not make them deny their conviction that on the third day he rose again!” That is why the Saviour’s men could do what the kings men and the presidents men could not!